Jump to content
 

Hornby AA15 Toad Brake Van


Tom F
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • RMweb Gold

Sometihg you shove through the wheel (Spokes or Hole) to stop it rotating. Sprags are known as "dregs" in some parts of the country.

 

They also had other uses being rather handy as packing when rerailing but rather more seriously, and because they were prone to damage in use, they tended to get used as firewood (especially in freight brakevans).

Link to post
Share on other sites

NCB tended to use steel for underground. About two foot long, two inches in diameter and tapered to a point. Usually with a circular disk (hand guard) welded to it to prevent the hand being drawn into the wheel sets but there were many styles.

 

This one which normally lives in my briefcase (don't ask) came from a colliery that was closed in 1873.

 

post-508-0-82573800-1482846448.jpg

 

 

 

 

  • Like 4
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

GWR Freight Brakevan Equipment

 

In 1936 -

Set of Side and tail lamps, oil can, hand brush, sand bucket, Short drawbar and hook, fire shovel, shunting pole, not less than 2 sprags, brake stick.

N.B/  The equipment as at 1936 was little changed from that of 1920 the only difference being the deletion, at some intermediate date, of two hand scotches from the list.

 

Revised during WWII  to read 'bucket' instead of sand bucket, and 'tail lamp and set of side lamps' instead of previous description.  Also the following items were listed as still allowing the van to be used in traffic if they were missing - hand brush, fire shovel, and bucket.

 

Further revised c.1959 to delete hand brush, firs shovel and bucket.

 

Revised 1960 to BR wide standard with the following list of equipment -

2 sprags, 1 shunting pole, 1 brake stick, 1 half gallon oil can, 2 side lamps, 1 tail lamp

 

Revised March 1968 to delete the sprags and add 2 sets of track circuit clips/

 

Revised December 1976 to delete the half gallon oil can  (but don't forget that a drop of lamp oil was helpful for getting the stove going ;) ).

 

Reissued June 1978 with no further changes.

 

The definitive and comprehensive list; thank you Stationmaster!  I have lit my share of stoves with lamp oil in the 70s, and fortunately was never called on to use the track circuit clips!

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Hesitating to ask this........but what's a sprag?

 

A thing for spragging, of course...

 

Piece of wood that you shoved between the spokes, or later into the holes, of wagon wheels to hold the wagon still on gradients.   That is why more modern 3 hole wagon wheels had holes.  They had a habit of breaking when the wagon was knocked about in shunting, and causing all sorts of diverting amusement. Sometimes you were amusingly diverted via a completely different route while the mess was cleared up...  Different from a chock, which fits between the wheel and the rail and is curved to fit the wheel; this more stick like device worked, when it worked that is, by jamming against the ground.  Obviously the success of this depended on the strength of the sprag and it was worth checking them for splits or other faults before trusting them.  I never liked the idea, but by my time their use was rare.  Very early in my railway career I saw one break in Aberthaw Cement Works; it went off like a gunshot, and would have decapitated anyone in it's path. Perhaps that is why I took against them so.

Edited by The Johnster
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

To get back to the Hornby van, I am looking forward to having one.  As Cwmdimbath needs one, I bought a Baccy toad recently, and was a little disheartened when I opened the box.  I've had 3 excellent wagons from Baccy in the last few months, an LNER 12ton van, an LNER steel open, and a Southern PMV, all in BR early 50s livery and pre-weathered in the case of the van.  They are excellent, and I doubt could be bettered without scratchbuilding to a very high standard; they are certainly better than anything I could build even from the very best available scratch.  The PMV is probably the most completely detailed and best finished model I have ever owned, and came out of the box like that! 

 

Back to the new Baccy toad; I bought it in BR unfitted grey, and have no complaints about the body moulding, livery, or printing.  I knew the handrails would be moulded but decided to live with that for now.  But, so far as I could make out, it is identical to a Mainline one I owned back in the early 80s, down to the brake blocks which are a scale foot or so outboard of the wheels; presumably ML thought that WR guards braked their trains by waving bits of cast iron in the fresh air!.  I still have an ML fitted toad body from those days running on an equally unrealistic Airfix chassis, and I'd have thought that some improvement might have been apparent over the years.  Come on, guys, at least put some windows in...

 

So I have very high hopes indeed for the Hornby toad, whatever the tubularity or otherwise of it's footboard hangers.  

I'll be quite happy thank you if it's got separate handrails (check), brake blocks that look as though they might be able to retard the wheels (check), sandboxes that don't look like plastic 4-pint milk cartons (check) and clear plastic in the windows if you cannot access the interior (not known yet).  A sanding lever that is not moulded on is a real bonus!  Especially if they're gonna be knocking them out at £22 a pop!

 

Mainline and it's descendants, and now Hornby if the photos show what the final shape will be, fit, or to be more accurate, mould, a sort of tapered upside down flowerpot thing for the stove pipe.  This does not match my recollections and is a surprisingly difficult thing to identify from photographs.  I assume it is correct; after all a firm that took so much trouble to get the alignments of it's brake blocks right wouldn't make an error of that sort, would they (ok, I'll take my tongue back out of my cheek now).  But I always cut these off and replace them with something a bit more parallel and stove-pipe like in blackened brass tube, and think I am making an improvement.  I cannot imagine that a stove pipe top of this tapered shape draws the fire particularly well, but of course I might be wroo, I mean wwwwng, I mean, can't type the word never mind say it, I mean I might be differently right!!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

The six lots of AA15 were produced over a longish timescale, and had differences.

 

I would advise Hornby to choose their running numbers and brandings from the penultimate lot (lot 901, numbers 68601-700), because this is the only lot that had GW boxes and the angle footboard stanchions, which is what Hornby are depicting.

 

Edit: Hmmm. Lot 888 might also be valid, depending on whether one believes the bible or the number in this Paul Bartlett collection: http://paulbartlett.zenfolio.com/gwrbrakevan/h361af2fe#h15d8eabe

 

 

On the matter of the 'bolted' L-section capping on the ends of the roof, I think that is a later 'modern' mod, but I can't put a date on it.

I own a 1924 V14 Mink A. It has the capping, as the bolts fit straight through to the frame hoop.

 

Ian

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

The chimney should be parallel, as you thought.

 

(It's just tapered on the model because of the release angle on the mould.)

 

Ah. that would explain it.  Thank you Miss Prism!  I shall continue to cut them off and replace them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't decipher the scribble on the AA3 GA, but I think the chimney diameter was between 4" and 4.25" diameter.

 

I have a higher resolution version (too big to post) & in that it's 4" dia. This corresponds with drawing 57077 'Stove for Breakdown Van' dated 12/1918, albeit for a different design of stove to that in the AA.3 drawing.

 

P.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

I can't decipher the scribble on the AA3 GA, but I think the chimney diameter was between 4" and 4.25" diameter.

 

In the past, I've gone for what looks right and whatever brass tube I've got handy.  Every time I've done it I've resisted the urge to put an orange or yellow led under the tube...  Now you have informed my of the diameter I'll try and get it in the ball park.  Thank you again!

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Just curious if anyone else has contacted Hornby about the axleboxes? I dropped them a line before Crimbo but aside from the automated response, haven't heard a peep from them acknowledging it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Yes, a rather good article by Hornby, but I don't think any Toads ran with split-spoke wheels. 10-spoke I think was normal for 20T Toads. (I wait to be shot down as usual!) Nice to see the correction to the footboard apertures, and Hornby could make a fortune if they sold those s/c buffers separately.

 

This is RTR of a very high standard.

 

Following your thoughts on the wheels, I did just take a glance through the photos I have of several preserved Toads. So far the only AA15 Toad I've seen which has got the 10-spoke wheels is the example which Hornby have been seen to measure up which is GWR 68684 at Didcot. This maybe why the Hornby model has been done with these wheels.

 

Besides 68684, I've only seen 10-spoke on AA21 17410 at the SVR and AA3 56400 at Didcot again. All other Toads I have photographed have 3 hole disc wheels. This is only speculation but it may just come down to whatever wagon wheels were around at the Swindon workshops, were used on the Toad in question.

 

7229099252_7305b1e57a_b.jpg

 

5561233775_b1254dfe34_b.jpg

 

5910462668_0b901858ea_b.jpg

Edited by Garethp8873
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Following your thoughts on the wheels, I did just take a glance through the photos I have of several preserved Toads. So far the only AA15 Toad I've seen which has got the 10-spoke wheels is the example which Hornby have been seen to measure up which is GWR 68684 at Didcot. This maybe why the Hornby model has been done with these wheels.

 

Besides 68684, I've only seen 10-spoke on AA21 17410 at the SVR and AA3 56400 at Didcot again. All other Toads I have photographed have 3 hole disc wheels. This is only speculation but it may just come down to whatever wagon wheels were around at the Swindon workshops, were used on the Toad in question.

 

7229099252_7305b1e57a_b.jpg

 

5561233775_b1254dfe34_b.jpg

 

5910462668_0b901858ea_b.jpg

Interesting you managed to get them with the same wheels but they all have different buffers.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Following your thoughts on the wheels, I did just take a glance through the photos I have of several preserved Toads. So far the only AA15 Toad I've seen which has got the 10-spoke wheels is the example which Hornby have been seen to measure up which is GWR 68684 at Didcot. This maybe why the Hornby model has been done with these wheels.

 

Besides 68684, I've only seen 10-spoke on AA21 17410 at the SVR and AA3 56400 at Didcot again. All other Toads I have photographed have 3 hole disc wheels. This is only speculation but it may just come down to whatever wagon wheels were around at the Swindon workshops, were used on the Toad in question.

 

7229099252_7305b1e57a_b.jpg

 

5561233775_b1254dfe34_b.jpg

 

5910462668_0b901858ea_b.jpg

 

 

Edited by tomparryharry
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

I know I'm 'resurrecting' a fairly old thread but does anyone know where the cheapest place to pre-order one is?

I usually find that amongst all well know online retailers "Rails Of Sheffield" are the cheapest. And their service is excellent too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...